SOLAR : My biggest mistake…by far!

Not all goes well on the glamstead, sometimes I make mistakes…sometimes BIG mistakes. Last month was one of those BIG mistakes. I cured it last week.

Back in JanuaryI got a call from my wife. She pleasantly, and without panic, asked me why the power went out in the house.

Let me explain…I have what is called a very boring solar system. It powers the house nicely and provides us all the luxuries and stability of a relatively normal life…without a utility bill or dependence on a power company. And it is boring! Meaning…I really don’t have to pay attention to the operation of the system…it just does it thing day in and day out…no issues,, no problems. Nice. But that all changed that day…

Fortunately I was on my way home and was only about 10 mins or so away. I asked her is there was any wire burning smell in the house. No. Then I asked if she would check for smoke or fire in the utility room where the solar equipment is located. Fortunately, she knows my humor and checked. Nothing. I’m glad I didn’t tell her I wasn’t joking.

I got home, verified the power was completely out in the entire house and headed to the utility room. In there I found the inverters off, the batteries offline, the computer brain showing an “alarm”, the charge controllers off, the system shutdown, no AC power at all.

The Victron CCGX “brain” or “computer” that controls/coordinates the system had an alarm “LVD Error”. Yeah, that means the system shut down due to low voltage coming from the batteries. I checked the SOC (State of Charge) lights on the batteries and it was showing about 75% of full capacity. That is not a low voltage problem at all. It simply made no sense.

I tried to troubleshoot what the problem was…or rather what the “real” problem was. I just couldn’t figure it out at all. Remember, I built the system, programmed the inverters, programmed the CCGX, programmed the charge controllers, made all the settings myself…I know my system pretty well. But, I still couldn’t figure it out.

Back about 400 years ago while I was also a firefighter, during my days off, I programmed computers. Okay, it was back in the late 80’s till about 2001. One of the things we had to do regularly in the early days was troubleshoot computer hardware along with the software. Sometimes with the computers themselves the only thing we could do to get it back up and running was the “BRB”…Big Red Button. On the early desktop computers there was a big red lever on the side of the case…the on/off button. Turn the computer off, wait a minute, turn the computer back on…problem solved, issue fixed…back up and running. Almost always worked for hardware problems.

Yup, I decided to shut down the entire system and restart it. Fortunately for me I’ve done it countless times and was no big deal…just think it through step-by-step. About 5 minutes later the system was up and running just fine, power to the house…and me left confused at what might have happened. The only thing I could figure out was some kind of “hiccup” occurred between the master battery computer management system (BMS) and the CCGX (the solar system computer/controller). And the system shut itself down to protect itself. Obviously since it came right back up without an issue, it had to be some false alarm/issue.

But…it exposed a much larger problem!!!

What if I had been out of town, or a couple of hours away? What if my wife hadn’t been able to get a hold of me? What if…

Yeah, even if my wife had gotten me on the phone but a couple hours away…could I have talked her through a system shutdown and restart? Maybe…but it would have been ugly trying to get her through each step in correct order to shut it down…then trying to get her through each step in correct order to do a restart.

Then my mind drifted to a couple other issues…using the generator with the system…and what about when eventually/if we sell the place. Yup, my OCD kicked in.

I have a document for the solar system that describes each piece of equipment and why I use it. It has a complete wiring diagram for each part of the system as well. That document is for anyone who has to work on the system besides me…they will understand how it is wired and what each piece of equipment is for. It’s like a technical manual. But, I don’t have an actual “operations guide”. Yeah it was obvious, that had to change.

So, over the course of several days I wrote, then edited, then edited it some more until I had a pretty dang good step-by-step manual that described:

  • How to completely shutdown the system,
  • How to start-up the system from a complete shutdown status,
  • How to hook-up the generator to by-pass the solar system,
  • How to hook-up the generator to supply power to the solar system,
  • How to remove the generator and remove it from the system, and shut down generator power.

Along the way I gave pretty good descriptions of solar system’s operations, including the “why” aspect. I used copious amounts of pictures with descriptions of lights, buttons, and levers. I had my wife look it over and she felt she could do any of the operations outlined in the manual…with just the manual.

Now, anyone…my wife, other technicians, a potential buyer, or a new owner can look at the operations guide and get a pretty good idea of how to run it. Also, combine that manual with the other “technical manual” I wrote, anyone could work on the system…or at least understand the how and why it was built, and how to operate it.

I sleep better at night now.

In case you want to see what the final product looks like I have attached it as a download. If you have a solar system, especially a DIY system, you might want to think about writing something to help others run your system safely.

So why was this “no manual” my biggest mistake so far? Simple, the safe operation, or any fixes, depended solely on me; avoiding a potential disaster for my wife if I wasn’t around to resolve the issue(s). Maybe preventing something worse.

You can download my Operations Guide (PDF file) by < clicking here > It might be helpful if you want to create one of your own.

I keep the guide book right smack dab in the middle of everything. Anyone can instantly know right where it is. Ah, no…there is no “red arrow” painted on the wall and equipment pointing to the manual.

The “tabs” are different manual parts; battery manual, inverter troubleshooting pages, &charge controller troubleshooting pages.

 

 

Box is built, problem solved????

This goes all the way back to a post back in mid-November. You can read about the original problem here < click here >

Today I am starting a thread to show what my “build” is and asking for feedback…ALL feedback. I welcome any warnings, questions, issues, problems, concerns, and advice…ANY feedback. I will post the rather rough/novice schematic, the outside and inside pictures, and a narrative for each part.

Please let me know what you are thinking!!

After no success in figuring out an off-the-shelf solution to controlling the well I decided that I had to build a solution that fit my particular need. Here are some of the ugly parts…

  • The original local dealer sold us a pump that didn’t meet our water supply needs when he could have if he had simply listened to us when we talked about the well depth, water needs, etc.
  • AND…the same dealer sold us that control module that was completely unneeded. There was a much less expensive and far simpler way to control the well pump.
  • When we worked directly with who we thought was the pump manufacturer, and who sold us the 2nd control module directly, they sold it when it was completely unneeded. Again, there was a much less expensive and far simpler way to control the well pump.
  • Neither the local dealer or the manufacturer had any solution for our situation.

But the real issue was…

  • The well control modules were getting zapped by transient voltage from nearby lightening strikes.
  • That transient voltage was coming in through the 700’ of buried signal wire between the storage tanks’ float switch and the well. Basically the wire was acting as an antenna collecting the voltage and shooting it into the electronic circuit board inside the well control module. And that very small voltage spike was killing the circuit board.
  • No off-the-shelf solution was available that wasn’t cost prohibitive. Meaning…thousands of dollars to install an applicable and reliable solution.

All we really needed was…

  • An easy way to be able to run the well from the solar panels or a generator.
  • A reasonable and realistic way to protect a control module and the well pump from lightening strikes. Obviously there is no way to protect from a direct lightening strike, at least one that is affordable, but I could expect protection from the transient voltage issues that was burning out the existing control modules.

Along the way I found out for basic operations the pump could run off solar panels or a generator very easily with nothing special needing to be done. The current well control module had no ability to implement that option. But, the well control module had options that meant absolutely nothing to me and were completely unneeded. After weeks of research, and a dozen emails back and forth to the “manufacturer” (turns out they were a distributor) I now understood how the pump worked, options for operation, and basically how it functioned overall. Interestingly enough…the pump itself was not “made” by the manufacturer, it actually was made in Italy and then private labeled by this company in Arizona. The pump is a really, really good pump!

So, all that being said…I just figured to build my own well control box/module.

Schematic…

 

 

 

 

 

Off-Grid Problems/Issues/Challenges…Part #1

I really want to write a little series of articles that, when combined, show a couple points that bug the crap out of me. But…I’m really not sure on where to start. Let me touch on the general points first, then maybe a starting point will manifest.

 

 

 

 

Points to Ponder –
  • You gotta know a bunch of stuff to go off-grid and/or work a homestead…or you need to be willing and able to learn.
  • Businesses are usually stupid…or don’t really care that much about their customers.
  • The simplest solution is usually the best/right solution.
  • There are some really great products out there…but they are usually really well hidden.
  • Don’t ever trust salesmen.
  • Mother nature rules…and can trash mankind whenever she wants.
  • Trying to be self-sufficient is a pain in the a$$…and expen$sive.

Yeah, you kinda get an idea of just how frustrated I might be?

Let me start all the way back at the beginning…

We bought our place 10 years ago…and I can’t express how grateful we are for God bringing us here. Fortunately for us it already had a well on it. Yup, that is an expensive necessity around these parts. Once we closed on the place I contacted a local well company to pull the pump and test the well…and refurb it if needed. We got lucky…the well was in great shape and needed no work on it.

There was no power at the well to run the pump and the pump, although working fine, was 30 years old and 220vAC. I went to a then local well supply house, outlined my situation, they recommended a new pump set-up, and we bought it. I installed it myself a couple years later and all was fine…till we needed to irrigate the garden, yard, and small orchard.

So we found out…not enough storage, not enough pump flow, WAY inconvenient to use a generator to run the pump…just not the right way to supply our water needs. So again, I contacted a now local solar business guy that I was friends with for advice. “Solar pump!!!” was his suggestion and he supplied me a quote. More money than we wanted to spend…but it “would cure our problems.”

I installed it myself and all was good…kinda. We weren’t getting the flow we needed (amount of water pumped out of the well) and we could only run the well during the day when the sun was shinning. And then disaster struck…a thunderstorm. “ZAP!!” A nearby lightening strike took out the well control module. It was under warranty but we had to send it in. Ahhhhhh…it would take at least a week, probably two, to get it back. Solution from the company…”buy a back-up controller”. Another $500 down the drain…but we kept on pumping.

Turns out that when the nearby lightening strike hit there was transient voltage that spread out towards our place and was absorbed by the signal wire between the well control module and the storage tank’s float switch…700’ in between. The hit wasn’t bad enough to show any damage on the controller’s circuit board…but enough voltage to kill the display board which in-turn killed the operational ability of the module.

Transient voltage refers to quick and very temporary spikes in electrical voltage, 
typically lasting only a few milliseconds. The spikes can be caused by near-by lightning strikes, 
switching operations, or electrical faults. And they can potentially damage sensitive electronic 
equipment such as circuit boards.

Float switch is a unit that floats in the water tank and tells the well pump 
when to turn on and send water to the tank and when to turn the well pump off
so the tank doesn’t overflow. 
Basically, and on/off switch controlled by the water level.

So a little time goes on and we expanded the orchard and garden and yard…now way too little water to irrigate. So, another storage tank. Fortunately a decent and reputable local company gave us a deal, installed the tank myself, back in business with plenty of water to irrigate.

Another thunderstorm…we noticed tanks overflowing sometimes. Three months of troubleshooting later…problems with the new well control module. Yeah, from you know what. Fixed it ourselves…back in business. Well, kinda. (no pun intended). We still had a problem getting enough water to irrigate the orchard, garden, berry patches, grass, and the new pine trees. Began a slow process to think about a better solution.

Another thunderstorm with a near-by lightening strike…a dead well control module…the new module now dead. No problem, I had a back-up on the shelf (the original control module), installed it, contacted the company, they said send in the dead unit. Turns out the unit was dead as a door nail…completely bricked. $500 down the drain. And the control module now on the well was the “repaired” unit from the first lightening strike and was/is limping along on borrowed time.

Fed up with the situation I decided I better get thoroughly educated on all aspects of the solar well set-ups and what exactly was causing our problems. Two months later I finally had a handle on it. The problems:

  • The well control modules were getting zapped by transient voltage from nearby lightening strikes.
  • That transient voltage was coming in through the 700’ of buried signal wire between the storage tanks’ float switch and the well. Basically the wire was acting as an antenna collecting the voltage and shooting it into the electronic circuit board inside the well control module.
  • No off-the-shelf solution was available that wasn’t cost prohibitive. Meaning…at a least couple thousand dollars to install an applicable and reliable solution.

But…here is the ugly part(s)…

  • The original local dealer sold us a pump that didn’t meet our water supply needs when he could have if he had simply listened to us when we talked about the well depth, water needs, etc.
  • AND…the same dealer sold us that control module that was completely unneeded. There was a much less expensive and far simpler way to control the well pump.
  • When we worked directly with the pump manufacturer, who sold us the 2nd control module directly, they sold it when it was completely unneeded. Again, there was a much less expensive and far simpler way to control the well pump.
  • Neither the local dealer or the manufacturer had any solution for our situation.

But is gets worse. I accepted the situation for what is was and knew I had to figure out a solution myself…so the research began. I found a wireless float switch that would eliminate the 700’ of signal wire that was collecting the lightening transient voltage…$800. But there still a problem with the well control module and it was going to breakdown at some point. Along with that bad news was some really good news…the pump itself was very high quality and had really great options. However, the control module we had/have couldn’t access those truly useful options.

Yes, I ordered the wireless float switch. Wanna hear some irony? 
The box with the new equipment arrived, a week after I made the purchase. 
I made time to start work installing it on the existing module for a test run. 
I set-up my camera to video the unboxing to post later. 
I pulled out the first two pieces of equipment...ah, that was all there was. 
The antennas, the tank probe, and some hardware were all missing!

Fortunately, I had the video. 
I called the company, explained the situation, told them about the video, 
and the really great customer service person created an order for the missing parts.
 They shipped the next morning.

A very awesome and needed option for the pump was…for basic operation the pump could run off solar panels or a generator very easily with nothing special needing to be done. The current well control module had no ability to implement that option. But, the well control module had options that meant absolutely nothing to me and were completely unneeded. After weeks of research, and a dozen emails back and forth to the “manufacturer” (turns out they were a distributor) I now understood how the pump worked, options for operation, and basically how it functioned overall. Interestingly enough…the pump itself was not “made” by the manufacturer, it actually was made in Italy and then private labeled by this company in Arizona.

The part that ticked me off the most…I could have had more than twice the pump/flow rate with the same type and quality of pump if the local guy had known what he was doing. He sold us a pump for a 750’ deep well vs. a pump for a 220’ well. Another model of that pump provides more than twice the flow rate for the same money for a 300’ well. Nothing I can do about that now…just move on.

So here is what I needed/wanted to control my well:

  1. Earlier in the day pumping and more water in the storage tanks during the summer months.
  2. A safe and reliable way to control the pump.
  3. An easy way to be able to run the well from the solar panels or a generator.
  4. A reasonable and realistic way to protect a control module and the well pump from lightening strikes.

Obviously there is no way to protect from a direct lightening strike, at least one that is affordable, but I could expect protection from the transient voltage issues that was burning out the existing control modules.

PROBLEM!!!! I couldn’t find anything to fit those requirements…nothing!

Come on…was I being unreasonable? I can’t be the first guy to run into this. And, it isn’t complicated. One limiting factor was my existing pump…I was stuck with it and its limiting flow rate. To replace it was simply too expensive. So I had to figure this out on my own. And I did!

I will write another article on what I am building for a solution…but, that isn’t the point of this article. Here I just want to point out the back-story and the lessons learned. I will do a “Part #2” that will be the lessons learned. Part #3 will be the overall solution to the problems/issues/challenges.

 


Related Articles –

 

Well Control Box Schematic

I am including the well box schematic below. Anyone’s input would be greatly appreciated…ANY! Yup, that means questions, concerns, issues, warnings, safety problems…and even compliment 😉

I am actually in the process of building the box right now…hurry, feedback needed.

Thank you !

  ( click image to enlarge )


Related Articles –

 

MCB Interlock

My experience with an MCB Interlock device has been a total success so far.

I needed to build a control box for my solar well. My solar well pump can directly accept AC or DC power. Part of the box build included an AC inlet for my genset and the incoming DC power from the PV array. I needed to make it easy to switch between power sources quickly and safely. And ensure that power could not come from both sources at once. Although highly unlikely that would ever be attempted, I wanted to ensure it as an impossibility. Hence, the “interlock” concept.

I first heard about their existence here on the forum, I don’t remember which thread. I purchased an interlock device off Amazon along with two Mollum MCBs; 20aAC and 25aDC. They arrived, and it didn’t work.

Problem: Mollum MCBs are not compatible with the interlock I purchased. Mollum breakers have the flip lever in the vertical middle of the unit. The interlock won’t slide with that configuration. So I purchased two Chtaixi MCBs after doing a bit of research (i.e. opening my eyes); its flip lever is located towards the bottom of the unit.

I Slid everything onto a DIN rail and it worked just as advertised.

So let me show you how it looks in my control box build…

AC power…

DC power…

But, here is a cool feature that I just stumbled upon…

Yup, when you want to lock out all incoming power from the genset or the PV array it turns into a “lock out”. Yeah, yeah…I know there is no place for a true padlock or even a tag to prevent sliding the interlock into operational capability. But, for me it is just a cool feature for added safety…not ultimate safety.

So, for a total of $48 I have the circuit breakers I need to disconnect power and protect the wire AND I have a device to safely and easily switch between power sources. Not a bad deal in my book.

If this is something that interests you…

The interlock: https://amzn.to/43JeNWI

AC MCB circuit breaker: https://amzn.to/3K7z29S

DC MCB circuit breaker: https://amzn.to/3Ko7xZH

MCB Interlock

My experience with an MCB Interlock device has been a total success so far.

I needed to build a control box for my solar well. My solar well pump can directly accept AC or DC power. Part of the box build included an AC inlet for my genset and the incoming DC power from the PV array. I needed to make it easy to switch between power sources quickly and safely. And ensure that power could not come from both sources at once. Although highly unlikely that would ever be attempted, I wanted to ensure it as an impossibility. Hence, the “interlock” concept.

I first heard about their existence here on the forum, I don’t remember which thread. I purchased an interlock device off Amazon along with two Mollum MCBs; 20aAC and 25aDC. They arrived, and it didn’t work.

Problem: Mollum MCBs are not compatible with the interlock I purchased. Mollum breakers have the flip lever in the vertical middle of the unit. The interlock won’t slide with that configuration. So I purchased two Chtaixi MCBs after doing a bit of research (i.e. opening my eyes); its flip lever is located towards the bottom of the unit.

I Slid everything onto a DIN rail and it worked just as advertised. So let me show you how it looks in my control box build…

AC power…

DC power…

But, here is a cool feature that I just stumbled upon…Yup, when you want to lock out all incoming power from the genset or the PV array it turns into a “lock out”. Yeah, yeah…I know there is no place for a true padlock or even a tag to prevent sliding the interlock into operational capability. But, for me it is just a cool feature for added safety…not ultimate safety.

So, for a total of $48 I have the circuit breakers I need to disconnect power and protect the wire AND I have a device to safely and easily switch between power sources. Not a bad deal in my book.

And yes, you can use two AC breakers or two DC breakers for switch between power sources.

< click here…AMAZON: Breaker Manual Locking Device >

 

Trouble in Solar Paradise

Twenty-two months ago I added a new 230ah 48v Trophy battery to our solar system. That coincided with a major upgrade to the entire solar system we have here at the glamstead. The system seriously changed our lifestyle in several ways; 1) air conditioning all night if needed, 2) bathroom electric baseboard heat 24/7 in the winter, 3) and double the AC power along with 240v capability. The system purred along flawlessly…until about 5 months ago.

Sometime in September (last year) I just happened to be in the utility room and I noticed that all batteries were charging, but the two Elite batteries (205ah 48v) were not displaying the same number of lights on the State of Charge (SOC) indicator. One was at 83% and the other was at 67% SOC but both were charging. I thought it was nothing more than a balancing issue so I basically ignored it. Ooooppppssssss…

A week later I was again in the utility room to get a tool on a cloudy day and I noticed that the lights were once again doing the same thing but not charging…it was 100% overcast. Now it got my attention. Fast forward 5 months…problem with one of our Elite batteries. From my best guess it is now at about 70 – 75% total capacity of the other Elite battery. Meaning it is now a 145 – 150ah battery. Not good, but not life endangering either. Obviously the battery has one or more weak “cells” in my way of thinking, the other cells are still doing their job.

Let me do a quick recap…I have 3 batteries in my solar system; a single 2-year old Trophy battery that is 230ah, and 2 Elite batteries that are 205ah each, totaling 640ah or 37.7kwh. Decent sized battery bank for an off-grid home. The two Elite batteries were bought at different times, 1 in early 2021, the other in late 2021. The Trophy battery was added in December 2022. All batteries match charging parameters (+/-.1volts).

I initially thought the batteries would eventually balance, match similar SOC, and maintain that for the most part. I was wrong. Each battery acts independent in charging and discharging…which actually turned out to be a blessing. The Elites generally discharge slightly faster than the Trophy and generally lag when charging. But no problems overall with maintaining a nice amount of power in the bank. Well, until I noticed the one Elite having an issue.

A visit to the shop where I bought them was warranted…for a warranty claim. (yes, pun intended) Ah, problem…the commie company in China that made the batteries was no longer around and not available to stand behind the warranty. That’s what I get for “bargain shopping” critical components. Yes, I did know what I was getting into at the time…money was an issue.

So here is where I’m at…battery bank is now at about 590ah vs 640ah. Let’s call it an 8% loss of power storage…maybe 10%. And on top of that…a weak battery with no idea for sure how long it will last. The good thing is that each battery is acting independently and doesn’t “draw-down” power from the other batteries to maintain the weak one. I guess it is a combination of the batteries’ BMS controllers and the design of the LifePo4 chemistry. But, I am still left with a somewhat bogus battery.

The owner of the shop where I bought it is also a very good friend of mine and felt terrible about the problem…but I was not the only person in the same boat…but he couldn’t stand 100% behind the warranty without the manufacturer supporting him. Unfortunate, but understandable. Given that he is a trustworthy person we came to a deal…he would do a “cost only” sale…and would do a trade for the amount due for something I had that he wanted and I could easily live without. Done! But here is where it gets interesting…

200Ah batteries are not cheap as of yet, although 100ah batteries have come down dramatically…now $800 – $1,000 all over the place. I will be the proud recipient of two of the new MidNite MNPowerflo5 Lithium Iron Phosphate server rack battery (100ah, 51.2v, 5.1kwh). The charge parameters are close enough to my existing batteries that there will be no issues. But WAIT you say! These are 100ah batteries not 200ah batteries…they won’t work!!! Ah, they will.

You see I will place the 2 new batteries together and parallel connect them together, then connect them to my Victron PowerIn bussbar unit. My system will then see the 2 new batteries as a single 200ah battery. And, each batteries BMS will control the batteries as needed during charge/discharge operations.

Here’s what the new battery bank will look like…

So a logical question would be…So these two new batteries replace the one existing weak battery? Nope!

The “weak” battery is still fully functional/operational at this point…just not maintaining its full capacity. So I will keep the weak battery in the bank and simply add the two new ones. Yup, that takes me from about approximately 590ah (30kwh) to 770ah (39kwh). Not bad, eh? And yes, I will keep a close eye on the weak battery and remove it from the bank if I notice it harming overall system operations.

Moral of the story…sometimes a problem turns into a blessing.

Also…I want to add into this conversation a point that I cannot stress enough. If you are going to have solar, especially if off-grid, it is essential to have some knowledge about how solar works…including the equipment specs and the general theories of each process step. Why? Can you imagine if a retail guy had installed the system, and I had the same problem, what would/could have been the outcome?

I can tell you this…based on people I know who were in trouble situations (i.e. not enough panels, not enough batteries, etc.) most solar companies would try and sell you a whole new system, or at least part of one) and make it sound like the only viable option. Why? Because an unknowledgeable solar system owner would have no idea that the real problem was only a single weak battery…an $1,800 fix vs laying out 10’s of thousands of dollars for stuff not needed.

Yeah, I can’t help myself…I will post about the install/upgrade and include pictures. And FYI…I got my hands on 6 more compatible solar panels so you know what that means…a new array for the system in the near future!!!


Related Articles –

Q & A Time…Ask me a question or send me a message…

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨





 

 

Iran’s attack on Israel – After Action Report

Yesterday Iran attacked Israel…and failed miserably. Iran was unable to accomplish any notable damage of significance. The only serious injury was a young child that was hit by shrapnel from an Iron Dome interceptor missile. Reportedly an Israeli airbase was hit but with little damage and no serious injuries. Iran failed in any military objective…except…

If I was Iranian military leadership and conducting an After Action Report (AAR) I would be embarrassed more than anything…unless…

From strictly a military perspective, last year’s October attack on Israel by Hamas was thousands of times more effective. But what does that have to do with yesterday’s drone and missile attack? Everything!

There is a lesson learned here for Iran…conventional warfare tactics won’t work against Israel.

Iran fired over 100 missiles and drones at Israel, including ballistic missiles. Not a single one made any real impact on any military or civilian target. Further, it showcased two things; 1) Israeli Iron Dome and Air Force can very effectively defend against such an attack, 2) It showed that countries can and will work together to defend Israel (i.e. Jordan and the US).

I am estimating that Iran spent somewhere in the neighborhood of $10,000,000 dollars yesterday in the attack. But it was a minimal price to pay for the lesson that they learned. And the $10,000,000 was probably reimbursed by either Obama or Biden’s cash payments over the last 15 years.

So what is next?

If Israel responds as history predicts and rhetoric sounds like at this point…Israel will strike out at Iran directly or at their proxies; maybe both. But they don’t need to.

Israel humiliated Iran yesterday…period. Everyone around the world, with any brain cells, can look at this attack as a complete and total failure on the part of Iran. It diminishes Iran’s political, diplomatic, and military power exponentially. It shows that they are a second rate military power (at best) with no ability to go head-to-head with Israel’s military. Humiliating for Iran!

If I was Israel I would play the diplomatic side of this…the “high road”. I would release a couple well-worded statements subtly insulting Iran’s capabilities, their weakness, their leadership, and showing Iran to be a bully that was disposed of quite easily.

At this point there is no effectual reason to strike back at Iran militarily. Israel has shown it can’t be bullied by a second rate military power…a tiger with no teeth or claws. If I was Israel I would concentrate on preparing to defend against another October 7th type attack…or some other unconventional attack.

Now here is the important part of all of this…

Beware of those calling for an attack against Iran, especially a joint operation.

This is the desire of ‘hawks’, ‘war-mongers’, those in the world’s military-industrial complex that would profit by yet another war in the world, or those simply confused in the difference between war and peace. Those calling for a military response strike against Iran only want to see destruction and death…they do NOT want peace in the world.

And ask the question, “Why don’t they want peace?

Think that one through for a while and you will see how the world is divided right now.

While your at it ask another question, “Do you honestly think that Iran thought they could get many, if any, of their drones and missiles through Israel’s defenses? So what might have been Iran’s real objective from that attack?


Related Articles –

 

Guerrilla Warfare by Gen. Grivas – How to Part #1

This series of articles is a ‘book report’…the CliffsNotes if you will…on a book written by General Georgios Grivas. General Grivas was a notable historic figure in Cyprus’ war of independence from British oppression and tyrannical rule in the 1950’s. He personally led the freedom forces of the EOKA’s fight for freedom from British domination and British violence against Cyprus’ people.

This article is meant to be a recap, or a guide, to how he was able to form one of the most effective guerrilla forces against an overwhelming professional army; an army that was one of the mightiest in the world at the time. I will add some modern day thoughts as I go regarding current organizational methods that have proven effective. Having taught incident management organization around the US for decades, I have some experience and knowledge in this area that I hope you might find all of this helpful in respect to history.

Please read the “NOTE/DISCLAIMER” at the bottom of the page for further clarification on why I wrote this series of articles.

Should the reader ever find themselves in a situation where their government is forcing tyranny and oppression America's Founding Fathers wanted to prevent tyrannyupon them…this might prove helpful. I am sure the colonial Founding Fathers would have thought this information useful 250+ years ago. Fortunately for us in the United States we have the Constitution and the ballot box to resolve our issues and be masters of our own destiny. So for those that live in the US, I hope you will find this article at least entertaining since the use of this information would hardly ever be applicable…would it.

Context & Background –

After WWII Cyprus found itself itself under British colonial rule. The British government ruled the island with oppression and tyranny. They would not eve entertain the idea that Cyprus would be allowed its independence to reunite with Greece, its historical and cultural homeland. To make matters worse, the British empowered the local Muslims from Turkey living on the island to play a major role in suppressing and oppressing the native Cypriots.

General Grivas, the author of the book, was born in 1898. At the age of 17 he applied for and gained entrance to Greece’s Military Academy. After WWI he joined the Greek army in their fight against the Turks. At the age of 26 he was a Captain in the Greek army and sent to France to attend advance military training courses. After returning to Greece he attended the War School in Athens where he received yet more advanced military leadership and tactics training. When Italy invaded Greece in 1940 he was a Lt. Colonel and served as Chief of Staff of the 2nd Army Division. Under brutal German occupation of Greece he formed and led resistance forces in Athens.

As Germans began their withdrawal in late 1944, Britain took control of Cyprus from the Germans, and the British oppression began. From 1944 onward Cyprus went through all international channels, including the United Nations to secure independence from Britain and to be allowed to reunite with Greece. All the diplomatic efforts failed due to vehement objections of both England and the United States. In 1948 discussion began among Cypriot leaders regarding overthrowing British rule. In 1951 it became official and the revolution was on…freedom and independence was their goal.

At the time Britain’s military might was overwhelming in both power and numbers. Cyprus could not begin to match England in conventional warfare terms. At that point a small guerrilla force of freedom fighters began waging a guerrilla war for freedom against one of the most powerful military forces in the world. The struggle against oppression and for freedom lasted until 1955 when British forces were defeated. On August 16, 1960 Cyprus gained its formal independence from the United Kingdom.

By odd circumstance I have a link to Cyprus. In 1974 the US Navy ship I was a crew member on was assigned to sail immediately for Cyprus. We were already on a deployment in the Mediterranean and we were the closest NATO ship in the area. We were prepared to place a small, heavily armed, landing party on the island to protect British citizens that had become trapped when Turkish Muslim troops invaded Cyprus and attempted to overthrow the island’s government. Fortunately for me, the landing party’s M60 gunner, US Marines flew in by helicopter just minutes before we were to land.

How To Start a Guerrilla Warfare Fight for Freedom Against Tyranny, Oppression, and Against All Odds…

Commitment & Loyalty –
  • Three personality weapons to overcome difficulties; 1) heart, 2) faith, 3) will for victory.
  • Freedom is never won without bloodshed.
  • Great things are never achieved without great danger.
  • All roads are open to the brave.
  • Prayer, “God guide me, I live with faith and the courage I shall succeed.”
  • ‘Right’ must be on the side of the guerrilla force, and must be seen as such by the general public. Example: foreign power invading and/or occupying a country thus eliminating/reducing freedom and liberty.
  • Understand that an occupying/oppressive struggle situation is unique in motive, psychology, and circumstance. All strategy, tactics, and planning must be designed and accomplished according to that uniqueness.
  • Guerrilla forces must clearly understand they are fighting for nothing less than freedom itself.
Leadership –
  • Principle to defeating the enemy; correct application of strategy and tactics would defeat the enemy however great his material resources.
  • When faced with overwhelming odds; brains, subtlety, and good planning in an underground movement can defeat any odds.
  • Nobody is born brave, but they can find bravery under the right leadership.
  • High quality traits of great leaders include; brave, humble, and frugal…all of which inspire respect and affection among good men.
  • Leaders must provide constant encouragement and clear orders (including clear leader’s intent) to subordinates to keep them focused on overall strategy.
  • A leader cannot sit back in safety and comfort while others risk their lives. When a leader offers/risks their life to the cause, faith and courage grow in their followers.
  • Pride, the opposite of humility, has no place in a leader and will lead to their destruction…all to often along with their followers. ‘Pride’ referred to here is not being teachable.
  • The biggest mistake a leader can make is painting an imaginary tactical picture he believes is true. Accurate Situational Awareness (SA) is of paramount importance. All barriers of accurate SA must be eliminated.
  • A leader must always speak the truth; he must not gloss over the difficulties, but give proof of his ability to overcome those difficulties.
  • A leader must not promise more than he can perform.
  • A leader must know his enemy, how his mind works, what their priorities are, and how to hurt them the most.

Notes From AH Trimble on leadership –

  1. What I have seen in good leaders:
    • Someone who listens to his people and takes their advice.
    • A person who trusts his subordinates and empowers them to make decisions and then act.
    • A person who always passes the credit to his people.
    • A person who accepts the blame when things goes wrong.
    • Someone who looks out for the benefit and welfare of the people they lead.
    • Someone who is willing to make a decision and stand by it.
    • A person who knows what they are doing and what they are talking about…”been there, done that” experience.
  1. Leader’s Intent always be present for all missions and must be clear, consisting of –
  • Task:  What it is to be accomplished.
  • Purpose:  Why it is to be done.
  • End State:  What it should look like when done and why.
  1. There is an integral part to completing the delivery of leader’s intent, “why” it needs to be successful. Without the “why” the subordinates are only being told what to do, not why it is so important. So you could say, the motivation is lacking. Anyone who has suffered in an organization where motivation is absent can attest to the likelihood of success in some new project. But, motivation doesn’t exist in a vacuum. Motivation will only exist where values are shared.
  2. To be a good leader you must take your vision and turn it into a mission statement…leader’s intent. Make it easy for others to see what you see…success. Give them a reason to move forward, to be successful, and to work together.

Strategy –
  • Small, compact groups working on a limited scale in numerous widespread areas.
  • Saboteurs would conduct operations in urban areas where plenty of targets existed.
  • All war is cruel, winning against superior forces is by ruse and trickery.
  • Strategy stays the same; tactics, carefully thought out in advance, could change based on circumstances.
  • Strategy elements will contain the following five tactical elements; attack, alertness, flexibility, secrecy, and speed.
  • Enemy numbers have little meaning when correct strategy and tactics are applied.
  • Let the enemy leadership know that it is their choices and their actions that result in guerrilla retaliation against them. You [the oppressors] strike us, especially civilians, retaliation will be swift and ruthless.

 < click here to read next article in this series >


Articles in this Series –

Related Articles –

 

 

- NOTE/DISCLAIMER -
Based on this day and age, in this stupid environment, 
I want to make it absolutely crystal clear that I am in no way condoning, advocating, or promoting; 
1)any violent action, 2) violence in any form, 3) or an uprising in any country anywhere in the world.
I am simply reporting on, relating, information and observations I made when I read the book
"The Memoirs of General Grivas" by Georgios Grivas.

 

Guerrilla Warfare by Gen. Grivas – How to Part #2

 

This is a 3-part series of articles, if you haven’t read the previous article in this series I would suggest you do. Otherwise, this article, taken out of context, may make little, if any, sense to you. And you may misunderstand the intent of the article as well. Please read the “NOTE/DISCLAIMER” at the bottom of the page for more clarification on why I wrote this series of articles.

< click here to read previous article – Part #1 >

Tactics Against Police –
  • Carry out murderous attacks against police officers who are out of sympathy with our aims or who hunt down guerrilla members.
  • Carry out ambushes against police patrols in towns or directly against police stations located in rural areas.
  • Restricting police movement, individual or groups, by the use of frequent and unexpected ambushes.
  • A benefit of ambushes, and especially police station raids, weapons and arsenals can be seized.
  • Unnecessary cruelty should be avoided; death/execution is not an unnecessary cruelty, torture is.
  • Be careful and skeptical of ‘imported’ police; they are often violently opposed to those they will police over. They are little more than hired thugs. When discovered, these individuals should become primary targets.
Tactics Against Occupying Military Forces –
  • Kill occupying service members, if they would kill guerrillas, if they could fire first.
  • Cooks, secretaries, and non-combatants should be spared unless they pose a threat.
  • Unnecessary cruelty should be avoided; death/execution is not an unnecessary cruelty, torture is.
  • The more enemy forces present, the more targets of opportunity exist.
  • Targeted attacks on occupying forces, groups or individuals, can have a very severe impact on their morale over time. The occupation forces will simply no longer see the benefit of dying “needlessly” and they will want to go home to their families, their homes, and their people.
Tactics Against Fellow Citizens –
  • Civilians who are traitors or enemy intelligence agents should be killed, and quickly.
  • Unnecessary cruelty should be avoided; death/execution is not an unnecessary cruelty, torture is.
Tactics Overall –
  • In areas where there are the fewest groups/teams, attack often and repeatedly.
  • After an attack, immediately empty the battlefield. Meaning, withdraw members entirely from the area for a period of time. When retaliation comes, there will be no guerilla forces for them to engage.
  • Careful study of the enemy’s habits is essential; their weakest point will surface. Place observation agents in the appropriate positions to best study enemy habits.
  • Be patient when being hunted after being surrounded. Often times the enemy may pass by very closely, if you open fire you can give away your position.
  • Whenever practical for a mission, hold back a reserve element to assist the primary group/team. This is especially true for any larger scale mission.
  • Spies and couriers should never have on their person anything that does not fit their cover story. When/if caught, there should be no possession on their body that is out of line with who they are pretending to be.
  • Speed of mission execution is vitally important. The ability to quickly act, or react, to any given situation is paramount to overcome the slow-acting bureaucratic processes of the occupying force’s leadership structure.
  • Even during times of group weakness when it is difficult to execute a mission, perform isolated acts of sabotage to show the enemy that they cannot do as they please no matter what.
  • A short period of extreme ruthlessness against opposition forces is a useful tool to dissuade them from actions against your guerrilla forces. This must be carried out with no restriction on action against those groups/individuals for a short period of time. And it must be well-known to them and everyone else why you are doing it and that retaliation stops abruptly when they cease their activities against your forces or civilians.
  • Any actions against civilians by the enemy must be met (retaliated against) quickly and with extreme measures. If enemy troops attack civilians it is best to execute any officer or non-commissioned officer involved. It that is not possible, the same retaliatory actions against enemy troops in another area can be just as effective as long it is is made known the action is a retaliatory strike in response to the original enemy’s attack on civilians. This type of ‘offset’ action may have the added benefit of creating division and animosity between the two groups of enemy troops. Meaning, one group suffers due to another group’s actions.
ORGANIZATIONAL PRINCIPLES –

MISSION: Group/team members must be able to perform in one or more of the following categories as ordered:

      1. Take part in mass demonstrations/protests.
      2. Conceal (hideout – give refuge to) other members of the organization.
      3. Participate in acts of violence.
      4. Obtain and/or pass on information regarding the enemy’s activities.
      5. Observe enemy agents.

Armed members are not to be used for any political purposes.

ORGANIZATION:
    • In every area there will be a leadership core located in the primary city/town. The person leading this HQ will be a District Leader (DLs) with a small staff who he hand picks.
    • DLs are responsible to the immediate next higher level of leadership, and no one else.
    • DLs may appoint Local Leaders (LLs) in specific areas within the District.
    • LLs are only responsible to their respective DLs.
    • Groups/teams will be formed by the DL and they will report directly to the DL in the absence of a LL.
    • Groups/teams may be temporary and modified as needed.
    • It is dangerous to increase the size of groups/teams beyond a certain point…called ‘saturation point’. Saturation point is usually no more than 5 – 6 members.
    • The size of a group/team is determined by; 1) terrain, 2) fighter skills, 3) food & supply requirements, 4) tactics, 5) need to keep causalities to a minimum.
    • When groups/teams grow too large, split them into smaller and independent units.
    • Groups/teams should always have a reserve force, unknown to the primary group/team. When the primary group/team becomes combat ineffective, the reserve group can be brought into play immediately.
    • Leaders, at any level, are only responsible to and only receive orders from their direct next level leader.

Notes From AH Trimble on organization –

  1. All organizations have the same basic 5 ‘needs’; 1) operations, 2) logistics, 3) planning, 4) administration, and 5) leadership (most of all).
  2. Logistics can/may acquire and distributes supplies, acquires and maintains facilities, provides transportation needs, provides communications capabilities, and provides long-term medical services.
  3. Planning can/may collects and process situation information and intelligence, determines need for any specialized resources for future operations, assembles information/intelligence on alternative strategies, provides predictions on operations potential, report any significant changes in operational status, and provides maps as needed.
  4. Administration can/may document all operations, provide reports up-line, and tracks funds received and spent.
  5. Operations is responsible for all tactical activities and may include intelligence gathering in place of Planning doing so.
  6. Leadership is responsible for the overall management of the incident, sets objectives & goals, responsible for, and authority over, all incident personnel, and ensures that Leader’s Intent is clear and known by all involved in any given operational activity.
  7. For more information on a near-perfect example of Operational Organization please refer to < click here to read more >

SELECTION of MEMBERS:
  • Selection and initiation of new member will be conducted in absolute secrecy to prevent revealing their identity generally. Only their direct leader will know who they are initially, once fully vetted, other team members may learn of them.
  • First names only will be used for identification; code name, or made-up name, can be used as a more secure alternative.
  • New members will be required to take an oath of allegiance.
  • New members must be made to understand and realize that any disobedience will be severely punished, including death for an egregious situation.
  • A new group/team will form with only 1 or 2 members and then expanded as needed and conditions require. The size of a group/team will generally be limited to a maximum of 5 – 6 members.
  • Only well-known, trusted, and reliable locals will be brought into a group/team.
  • The objective is quality members not quantity when recruiting new members.
  • New members will be assigned to one or more of the categories above, i – v.
  • Member identity, as far as practical, should be kept from one another; especially member identities between different groups. This restriction of identity should also apply to responsibilities and mission activity.
  • Members should not discuss any part of their group/team membership or activity with anyone outside of the group/team. Members should minimize and discussion within a group/team with other members not directly involved in a mission or activity.
  • Enlisting men of bad character will result in significant problems within the group/team and carrying out missions.
  • Attractive women can attract considerable attention, and can act as diversion.
  • Less-attractive women can often pass totally unnoticed, drawing little, if any, attention.
  • Appropriate punishment does not humiliate the good soldier, if no dishonor is involved.
  • In times of trial a true fighter shows how he can face trouble with courage and calmness.
COMMUNICATIONS:
  • Rapid and secure communication within a group/team, and with the next level leadership, especially on short notice, is essential. Couriers (d) should be reliable, secure, and safe.Communications is the number one problem in emergencies and disateres
  • Couriers should be responsible for carrying out their responsibilities independent of the group/team, including leadership.
  • Couriers/communications share ‘first essential’ with intelligence personnel. All involved must be thoroughly trained in communications security.
  • Any scientific means of communications can be compromised.
  • Manual communications (i.e. hand-carried notes) are more secure than scientific means.
  • Violations of communications standards and disobedience are rapidly dealt with through severe disciplinary measures, including death.

Notes From AH Trimble on communications –

  1. Communications security (ComSec) is of paramount importance. < ComSec – What is it and how do I use it? >

< click here to read previous article in this series >            < click here to read next article in this series >


Articles in this Series –

Related Articles –

 

 

- NOTE/DISCLAIMER -
Based on this day and age, in this stupid environment, 
I want to make it absolutely crystal clear that I am in no way condoning, advocating, or promoting; 
1)any violent action, 2) violence in any form, 3) or an uprising in any country anywhere in the world.
I am simply reporting on, relating, information and observations I made when I read the book
"The Memoirs of General Grivas" by Georgios Grivas.